Ivan Rodriguez*, Magglio Ordonez*, Placido Polanco, Carlos Guillen, Justin Verlander
2006
Ivan Rodriguez, Magglio Ordonez, Kenny Rogers
2005
Ivan Rodriguez
2004
Carlos Guillen‡, Ivan Rodriguez*
2003
Dmitri Young
2002
Robert Fick
2001
Tony Clark
2000
Todd Jones
1999
Brad Ausmus
1998
Damion Easley
1997
Justin Thompson
1996
Travis Fryman
1995
David Wells
1994
Travis Fryman, Mickey Tettleton
1993
Cecil Fielder, Travis Fryman
1992
Travis Fryman
1991
Cecil Fielder*
1990
Cecil Fielder, Alan Trammell
1989
Mike Henneman‡
1988
Doyle Alexander‡, Alan Trammell*†
1987
Jack Morris, Matt Nokes, Alan Trammell, Lou Whitaker†
1986
Willie Hernandez, Lance Parrish*, Lou Whitaker*
1985
Willie Hernandez‡, Jack Morris*, Lance Parrish*†, Dan Petry, Alan Trammell, Lou Whitaker*
1984
Willie Hernandez, Chet Lemon*, Jack Morris, Lance Parrish*, Alan Trammell†, Lou Whitaker*
1983
Aurelio Lopez‡, Lance Parrish, Lou Whitaker
1982
Lance Parrish
1981
Jack Morris*
1980
Lance Parrish, Alan Trammell
1979
Steve Kemp
1978
Jason Thompson
1977
Mark Fidrych†, Jason Thompson‡
1976
Mark Fidrych*, Ron LeFlore*, Rusty Staub*
1975
Bill Freehan‡
1974
John Hiller‡, Al Kaline
1973
Ed Brinkman, Bill Freehan‡, Willie Horton
1972
Norm Cash, Bill Freehan*, Mickey Lolich
1971
Norm Cash*, Bill Freehan*, Al Kaline, Mickey Lolich
1970
Bill Freehan*, Willie Horton
1969
Bill Freehan*, Mickey Lolich‡, Denny McLain
1968
Bill Freehan*, Willie Horton*, Denny McLain, Don Wert
1967
Bill Freehan*, Al Kaline*†, Dick McAuliffe
1966
Norm Cash, Bill Freehan*, Al Kaline, Dick McAuliffe*, Denny McLain*
1965
Bill Freehan*, Willie Horton*, Al Kaline, Dick McAuliffe*
1964
Bill Freehan‡, Al Kaline†, Jerry Lumpe‡
1963
Jim Bunning, Al Kaline*
1962 (Game 2)
Hank Aguirre, Jim Bunning‡, Rocky Colavito, Al Kaline
1962 (Game 1)
Hank Aguirre‡, Jim Bunning, Rocky Colavito
1961 (Game 2)
Jim Bunning, Norm Cash*, Al Kaline
1961 (Game 1)
Jim Bunning, Norm Cash*, Al Kaline, Frank Lary
1960 (Game 2)
Al Kaline, Frank Lary
1960 (Game 1)
Al Kaline, Frank Lary
1959 (Game 2)
Al Kaline, Harvey Kuenn†
1959 (Game 1)
Jim Bunning, Al Kaline, Harvey Kuenn
1958
Al Kaline, Harvey Kuenn
1957
Jim Bunning*, Al Kaline*, Harvey Kuenn*, Charlie Maxwell
1956
Ray Boone, Al Kaline*, Harvey Kuenn*, Charlie Maxwell‡
1955
Billy Hoeft‡, Al Kaline*, Harvey Kuenn*
1954
Ray Boone*, Harvey Kuenn‡
1953
Harvey Kuenn
1952
Vic Wertz‡
1951
Fred Hutchinson, George Kell*, Vic Wertz
1950
Hoot Evers*, Ted Gray, Art Houtteman, George Kell*
1949
George Kell*, Virgil Trucks, Vic Wertz
1948
Hoot Evers*, George Kell‡, Pat Mullin*, Hal Newhouser
1947
George Kell*, Pat Mullin‡, Hal Newhouser*, Dizzy Trout‡
1946
Hal Newhouser
1945
Hank Greenberg‡ (See note at bottom)
1944
Pinky Higgins, Hal Newhouser, Dizzy Trout‡, Rudy York‡
1943
Hal Newhouser, Dick Wakefield*, Rudy York
1942
Al Benton, Hal Newhouser‡, Birdie Tebbetts*, Rudy York*
1941
Al Benton‡, Birdie Tebbetts‡, Rudy York*
1940
Tommy Bridges‡, Hank Greenberg*, Bobo Newsom
1939
Tommy Bridges, Hank Greenberg*, Bobo Newsom‡
1938
Charlie Gehringer*, Hank Greenberg†, Vern Kennedy‡, Rudy York
1937
Tommy Bridges, Charlie Gehringer*, Hank Greenberg‡, Gee Walker†
1936
Tommy Bridges†, Charlie Gehringer*, Goose Goslin, Schoolboy Rowe
1935
Tommy Bridges‡, Mickey Cochrane‡, Charlie Gehringer*, Schoolboy Rowe‡
1934
Tommy Bridges‡, Mickey Cochrane, Charlie Gehringer*
1933
Charlie Gehringer*
Note: No game was played in 1945, although teams were selected
* Voted to start or started
† Selected but replaced due to injury
‡ Selected but did not appear in game